open response to Free Press Unlimited

Open Response to Free Press Unlimited

I have just received a “right to reply” email from an organisation called Free Press Unlimited.

Reading it, I get the impression that another heavily government-funded NGO is preparing a report about a shadowy network of Jews, and those who defend them, supposedly working together in a sinister campaign to corrupt the world’s morals and get away with murder.

It is an ancient antisemitic trope repackaged for modern consumption. Once upon a time, Jews were accused of murdering Jesus. In the modern version, Jesus has been replaced by Palestinian children, medical workers or, in this particular case, journalists.

The underlying narrative remains depressingly familiar: Jews operating through a coordinated network, manipulating information, concealing wrongdoing and conspiring to escape accountability for terrible crimes.

The accusers also remain familiar: a group of morally superior people in Europe, afforded power by the state, who believe they belong to a “community of the good” and seek to ostracise all non-believers. That their targets just happen to be mostly Jews – representing just 0.2% of the world’s population – is pure coincidence, of course.

Free Press Unlimited is a Dutch organisation that claims to defend press freedom. And apparently, because of my work exposing the terror ties of some people wearing press jackets in Gaza, I am among those Jews it has decided to smear.

What appears to be taking shape is an attempt to demonise Jews and those who defend Israel, portray independent investigations as part of a coordinated Israeli campaign – because apparently Jews cannot possess independent agency – and whitewash Gazans wearing press jackets whose documented ties to terrorist organisations deserve serious scrutiny.

Rather than confront the evidence, or actually defend “press freedom”, the apparent objective of Free Press Unlimited is to discredit journalists who are working to discover the truth.

I have published FPU’s email in full for anyone interested in reading it.

As is my style, I have absolutely no intention of responding to their half-baked, inconsistent and, in places, truly absurd allegations in a manner that allows them to cherry-pick my words, butcher my arguments or strip my response of context.

So I am responding publicly, where everyone can read their questions, my answers and the supporting evidence in full – and judge for themselves.

I hope you enjoy the ride.

My Response to Free Press Unlimited

Dear Jasmijn de Zeeuw, Investigations Unit, Free Press Unlimited,

Thank you for your email, and for your remarkable ‘generosity’ in allowing me just 48 hours to respond.

Given the depth and seriousness of the matters being discussed, methinks you could learn something about providing those you seek to delegitimise with a meaningful opportunity to respond to complex and potentially damaging allegations.

As it stands, your demand for such a rapid turnaround reeks of student activist journalism and says much about the type of report your team is likely to produce.

As will become clear below, that first impression appears to have been well-founded.

A little about me.

I am not a weak-kneed Jew who becomes intimidated when hard-left activist NGOs come knocking. I have been doing this for a long time, and you are certainly not the first to attempt to discredit me with half-baked claims built on misrepresentation, cherry-picking and straw-man arguments.

As is my practice, I prefer full transparency and so choose to respond on my own website. Your email has also been republished in full.

This ensures that everyone can see precisely what you have alleged, examine the evidence for themselves, and judge just how weak your arguments really are.

Beginning at the End

Your organisation claims to defend press freedom, yet here you are, preparing a report that seeks to discredit and delegitimise my work as an independent journalist.

Why? Because you politically disagree with my findings.

That alone suggests your commitment to press freedom extends only as far as the boundaries of your own Overton window.

To illustrate just how far your organisation has lost its way, I want to begin at the end – quite literally – by drawing attention to the footer of your email.

I do so because I believe it encapsulates the farcical position your organisation has adopted.

This is the image you chose to display in your email footer:

Hind Khoudary, Free Press Unlimited footer

The person you have chosen as a face of Gazan journalism is Hind Khoudary.

Interesting choice. Hind Khoudary has been on my radar for over seven years. I want to highlight just three examples from her social-media history:

The first is a repost from 2019. Khoudary amplifies a post that explicitly celebrates and glorifies armed martyrdom. It even suggests there is no better way to enter paradise than with a machine gun on your shoulder:

Hind Khoudary, Glory in martyrdom

The second is a post from 2020. Khoudary publicly denounces a Gaza-based peace activist, tagging Hamas officials to draw their attention to him. Her words leave little doubt that she wanted action taken against him. He was arrested shortly afterwards:

Hind KHoudary, Hamas snitch

The third is perhaps even more relevant to the subject of journalism. In another repost, Khoudary amplifies a call for self-censorship, which explicitly instructs people to use their pens to support the resistance:

Hind Khoudary, censorship

There are other examples, but these three alone paint a disturbing picture.

Here is someone who has amplified the glorification of armed martyrdom, publicly denounced a peace activist while tagging Hamas officials, and circulated calls for writers to impose self-censorship in support of the resistance.

And this is the person you have chosen as a symbol of press freedom?

An organisation supposedly dedicated to protecting independent journalism has chosen to showcase a terrorist supporter who handed a freedom fighter to Hamas, and amplified a call for journalists to censor themselves in the interests of the “resistance”.

The irony is staggering.

Your moral radar really has stopped functioning.

And yet you have the audacity to investigate and attempt to discredit journalists who expose precisely this kind of behaviour.

Given the above, it is difficult to take your organisation seriously. I continue to respond only so that others can see just how profoundly lost your organisation has become.

My report on the Gazan ‘Journalists’

Much of your email focuses on a report I published in January 2024 titled The ‘Journalists’ of Gaza. It was an extensive investigation into individuals identified as journalists killed during the opening months of the Gaza war.

As far as I am aware, I was the first to undertake in-depth research into a widely promoted activist narrative claiming that Israel was deliberately targeting journalists. Rather than simply accepting the claim, I set about investigating it.

What I uncovered raised serious questions about the classification systems and research undertaken by organisations such as the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ).

It is this report you appear to have had the most trouble digesting.

Which raises an obvious question: at what point did investigating wartime claims become an illegitimate activity in the eyes of an organisation supposedly dedicated to press freedom?

Sloppy Misrepresentation

Reading your allegations, it becomes immediately apparent that either you have serious comprehension problems, have not read my report in full, or have deliberately set out to discredit me with little concern for facts.

Take your primary complaint that I “applied my own threshold in the report as to whether the killing of a journalist in armed conflict is legitimate.”

My report does no such thing.

You have made that up.

The journalist directory you refer to as evidence was compiled using strict criteria for identifying individuals who had publicly expressed support for terrorism against civilians. Those criteria determined inclusion in a research directory. Nowhere do I claim that meeting those criteria makes someone a legitimate military target.

Calling someone’s background into question, investigating their affiliations, or uncovering evidence that challenges the public narrative surrounding them is not the same as declaring them a lawful target.

You have taken a research methodology and falsely presented it as a justification for military targeting.

The irony of an organisation making unsubstantiated allegations to undermine my credibility as an investigative journalist should not be lost on anyone reading this.

Is the rest of your investigation conducted to the same standard?

Judging by the other allegations in your email, I have every reason to suspect that it is.

Error After Error

You accuse me of misrepresenting CPJ’s methodology while repeatedly defending a classification system whose failings can be exposed through relatively straightforward investigation.

CPJ’s own methodology requires a connection between a journalist’s death and their work. Yet its handling of Gaza casualties raises serious questions about how that connection is established.

Let me give you one example, Ahmed Shehab:

Ahmed Shehab is listed on CPJ’s website as having been killed on 12 October 2023.

CPJ claims its listings are “independently confirmed through information from at least two credible sources.”

Yet its listing for Ahmed Shehab cites the Palestinian Journalists’ Syndicate (PJS) and the London-based Al-Araby website.

But Al-Araby’s own report relies entirely on the PJS for this information.

In other words, CPJ presents two sources when both lead back to one. This is circular sourcing, not independent confirmation.

These are undergraduate research errors, not the standards expected of a supposedly authoritative organisation.

But it gets worse.

Who Was the Real Target?

Shehab worked for Sowt al-Asra (Voice of the Prisoners), a radio station established within a Palestinian Islamic Jihad-affiliated media network. Islamic Jihad is a proscribed terrorist organisation in the UK, EU and United States.

CPJ classifies Shehab’s death as occurring during a dangerous assignment. Yet he was killed in a residential strike involving his extended family.

So what dangerous assignment was he undertaking?

And this is where the story becomes considerably more revealing.

The strike was an event involving the Shehab family. Among those killed was Ahmed’s uncle, Abd al-Rahman Shihab, a senior Palestinian Islamic Jihad figure.

Abd al-Rahman’s importance within Islamic Jihad is not speculation. His organisational history was documented long before the war, and Islamic Jihad itself announced his death on 12 October 2023, identifying him as one of its leaders and stating that the Israeli strike had targeted his home:

Free Speech Unlimited

We therefore have a man employed by an Islamic Jihad-affiliated radio station, killed in a bombing that also killed a senior Islamic Jihad leader, whose home was reportedly struck.

Where is the evidence that his journalism had anything to do with his death?

Isn’t the presence of a senior Islamic Jihad figure, killed in a strike, an obvious alternative explanation that any serious investigation should examine?

This example is far from alone and creates a clear need for journalists to investigate these cases and the way they are being reported.

And it is precisely the sort of investigation you seek to discredit.

Circular Reasoning and Baseless Allegations

It gets even more surreal. You accuse me of asserting that “journalists killed at home should not be included in the database.”

This is simply not true. Nowhere in my report do I suggest such a blanket exclusion.

You are making stuff up again.

I said that CPJ misrepresents the circumstances of deaths when it lists people killed at home as having died on a “dangerous assignment.”

Being killed at home raises questions requiring further investigation, because the truth can become lost in the “fog of war”.

I am doing exactly what a good investigative journalist should do.

For example, all three of these “journalists” died at home:

Two of the three worked for media outlets associated with Islamic Jihad or Hamas.

This brings me to another of your nonsensical allegations – that I rely on guilt by association and consider such associations sufficient to make someone a legitimate target.

I do no such thing. You are making stuff up again.

In fact, I explicitly excluded individuals from my directory where family members’ statements suggested an affiliation but I lacked sufficient evidence to establish it.

Had you thoroughly read my report, you would have seen evidence of these exclusions (pages 38-39). So either you are selectively extracting material or you have not read the report properly. Either way, you should be ashamed of the standard of your research.

Your comment also betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of how Gazan society operates. Gaza is a clan-based society, where family networks and affiliations can be highly significant. Judging events through naive Western assumptions risks missing crucial context.

That is why, when someone employed by a Hamas or Islamic Jihad media outlet is killed at home, it becomes imperative to investigate who else was present.

Jamal Haniyeh, the grandson of the Hamas leader, still appears on the CPJ list. How can CPJ know whether he was the intended target, whether he had activities beyond journalism, or whether someone else at the location was the actual target?

CPJ appears to be imposing Western assumptions about journalists working from home onto the realities of Gaza. Someone working for a terrorist organisation who is killed in a midnight strike alongside family members was not out reporting the news, and there is no reason to automatically assume they were even the intended target.

Not that anything in your allegations suggests this level of understanding.

Which is why I stand by my criticism that CPJ appears more interested in inflating its numbers than ensuring their accuracy.

In the end, you resort to circular reasoning, citing CPJ’s subsequent casualty figures as proof that my criticism of its methodology was flawed. You even suggest that the higher number makes my criticisms “absurd”.

Do you understand how childish this is?

Just How Sad You Must Be

There is one final point that I believe highlights just how lost you have become.

You claim that your report refers to my work exposing the viral media lie that Mohammed Al-Matouq was a healthy child who had become a victim of Israel’s alleged deliberate starvation policy, supposedly responsible for widespread famine.

This was a baseless antisemitic libel that spread around the world, with countless front pages carrying a story that simply was not true.

Following my research, newspapers around the world issued corrections:

Yet somehow, you have included this to attack me. Worse still, you reference Human Rights Watch (an activist NGO, not a journalism organisation) in an attempt to justify the error.

It is absolutely astonishing that you are attacking the journalist who exposed the falsehood, rather than those who published it.

As if the truth does not matter at all.

Which explains exactly why you are writing your report.

Regards,

David Collier

 

Help Me Fight Back Against Antisemitism and Misinformation

For well over a decade, I’ve been researching and exposing antisemitism, historical revisionism, and the distortion of truth. My work is hard-hitting, fact-based, and unapologetically independent.

Everything I produce is entirely community-funded. That independence allows me to speak freely and without compromise.

If you value this work and want to help me continue, please consider making a donation. Your support genuinely makes this possible.

You can donate via PayPal using the button below:

Alternatively, you can donate through my PayPal.me account or support my work on Patreon.

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.