Dear Mr Collier,
I am reaching out on behalf of the international press freedom organization Free Press Unlimited. We would like to invite your response to findings we will publish in a forthcoming report about the delegitimisation of Palestinian journalists before and after they were killed, in particular the cases of Anas Al-Sharif and Hossam Shabat.
To ensure that we accurately reflect any views or actions taken by you in relation to the matters included in the report, we respectfully request your response by 18 November 2026. Please find a summary of the key findings of the report at the bottom of this email.
- The report identifies you as part of ‘a network of official and independent actors who were involved in constructing and amplifying delegitimization narratives’ about Palestinian journalists and their work. The report notes that you are a recurring name in messaging about allegations against Palestinian journalists and their work and discredit NGOs and media who write about killings of Palestinian journalists by Israel. The report refers to the following posts and reports:
https://x.com/mishtal/status/1849092993954844826?a=zv2tFfAfHaNL4X2-VxY&s=20
https://x.com/mishtal/status/1744639802723471821
https://david-collier.com/the-lie-about-palestinian-journalists/
https://x.com/mishtal/status/1954807768080118094
https://x.com/mishtal/status/1954813998961991884
https://x.com/mishtal/status/1954820149854249316
https://x.com/mishtal/status/1954898251146248677
https://x.com/mishtal/status/1955155413172711451
https://x.com/mishtal/status/1955556728214331575
- The report discusses your report of 9 January 2024 (https://david-collier.com/the-lie-about-palestinian-journalists/) and notes that:
- Without providing evidence of this claim, you assert in the report that ‘like Hamas, ‘it is in the interest of the Committee to Protect Journalists to push these numbers as high as possible’
- You apply your own threshold in the report as to whether the killing of a journalist in armed conflict is legitimate (referring to your criterion from the journalist’s directory ‘A search was made for definitive and visible support [on social media] for terrorism against civilians’), as opposed to the threshold applicable under international humanitarian law, which is applied by CPJ.
- CPJ already at the time stated under each entry that its research, given the complexities of covering armed conflict, is based on preliminary reporting and will be updated when new information becomes available. The report notes that CPJ continuously updated its data when new information became available and held an audited review in 2026. The report notes that, of the 19 journalists you argue should be removed from the CPJ-list (p. 12-42), CPJ removed two in 2026 when new information showed they had been engaged in combat, while one had already been removed in 2024 for this reason. 2 journalists were removed (one already in 2024) when new information showed they were not journalists. The other 14 were maintained on the list, and additional sources reconfirmed their status. Moreover, by the time of the review, the audited review confirmed that an additional 175 Palestinian journalists were killed by Israel in Gaza;
- That, in light of the above, you cite selectively from CPJ’s methodology in the report (as available on its website at the time) – only referring to the two sources the organization seeks, and not the efforts it stated to undertake to subsequently identify additional information before adding a name to the database;
- You applied arbitrary criteria, such as the assertion that journalists killed at home should not be included in the database;
- And regularly imply guilt by association, such as in sentences like ‘this is an image of his cousin – not him. The respectful response is his. But it does raise questions about how close to his household Hamas may have been’;
- And lastly, the report in this section notes that while debate about the various databases of journalist killings is important and legitimate, your report makes various unsubstantiated allegations, including against CPJ and its staff, and dismisses concerns over journalist killings by Israel alltogether as ‘fiction’ and propaganda. The over 170 journalists killed by Israel in Gaza, Iran, Lebanon and Yemen that CPJ recorded since your report underline the absurdity of these claims, but also point at the painful lack of accountability after journalist killings started to rise early in the war.
- The report refers to your ‘exposé of the ‘face of famine Mohammed Al-Matouq’ as an example of your influence on the information ecosystem described in the report. The report notes that human rights organisations such as Human Rights Watch have pointed out that the fact that Al-Matouq had a pre-existing condition only made him more vulnerable to starvation, and underlines that information from among others the IPC, which at that the time reported that over 20,000 children had been admitted for treatment for acute malnutrition between April and Mid-July 2025, confirmed the urgency of the situation your expose undermines as a ‘famine narrative’ meant to ‘enable Hamas’.
(https://www.ipcinfo.org/ipcinfo-website/countries-in-focus-archive/issue-133/en/).
Any response received before November 18th will be incorporated in the report. If you have any questions, please contact me at jdezeeuw@freepressunlimited.org. We thank you in advance for confirming receipt of this email.
On behalf of the Investigations unit at Free Press Unlimited,
Your sincerely,
Jasmijn de Zeeuw
Summary of key findings
The report analyzes public and online statements in which official and independent actors have referred to the two Palestinian journalists as terrorists, propaganda operatives, or participants in hostilities without providing credible evidence of these allegations. In the report, we refer to these allegations as ‘delegitimisation narratives’: efforts beyond legitimate media criticism, in which journalists are portrayed in a way that discredits their status as a journalist or their journalistic credibility, without providing credible evidence of such allegations. FPU conducted digital and open source research to answer the research questions: ‘How have delegitimisation narratives around killed Gazan journalists been constructed?’ and ‘How did these narratives reach legacy media – and thereby large audiences?’.
With regard to the allegations issued against Anas al Sharif and Hossam Shabat, the report outlines the applicable legal framework under international humanitarian law, which prescribes that journalists can only be legitimate targets during armed conflict if and for so long as they participate directly in hostilities. The report finds that the IDF provided no credible evidence that meets this threshold, nor that supports the allegations made in these two cases. The report notes, among others, that the screenshots the IDF distributed to substantiate its allegations were unverifiable due to Israel’s refusal to release the original documents, remain uncorroborated, and do not contain evidence relevant to the applicable legal threshold (both in time and scope). With regard to materials shared by other actors, including photos of the journalists with leaders of a terrorist organisation or posts from their social media accounts, the report notes in reference to the applicable legal framework (including the interpretation by the Israeli authorities) that the mere expression of political thoughts or (alleged) sympathies with a party to the conflict are not sufficient to demonstrate that a journalist has ‘participated directly in hostilities’, and thereby do not justify any attacks against them.
To research the aforementioned questions, the report relies on two methods: a chronological reconstruction of the delegitimisation campaigns that targeted Anas Al-Sharif and Hossam Shabat, analysing social media activity, official statements, thinktank publications and other publicly available material. Second, an examination of 98 publications from 14 major legacy media outlets across seven Western countries to assess how allegations against the two journalists were reported.
The first key finding is that delegitimisation narratives about Al-Sharif and Shabat were constructed and amplified through a specific network of both official actors, meaning (individuals employed by) the IDF and other Israeli government bodies, and independent actors. Our findings show that actors in- and outside the Israeli government and IDF reinforced each other’s messaging about the journalists by reposting and adding to the same narratives, exchanging information about the journalists (e.g. OSINT-researchers handing over ‘evidence’ to the IDF and meeting with IDF officials), attending meetings organized by government bodies in which messaging was coordinated, and in some cases, even engaged in paid collaborations with Israeli ministries. In both cases, our analysis demonstrates that delegitimisation followed a recognisable pattern, moving from allegations of propaganda to allegations of terrorism.
During periods of heightened international criticism of Israeli military operations, delegitimisation activity intensified considerably. Second, our analysis of legacy media demonstrates that these narratives were frequently reproduced by international legacy media in ways inconsistent with fundamental journalistic safeguards. Despite the severe nature of the allegations, for example, more than 72% of the publications about Al-Sharif and Shabat did not demonstrate any attempts to independently verify allegations of terrorism made against the journalists. While the severity of these shortcomings varied, together they contributed to the wider dissemination and normalisation of these unsupported and severe allegations.
The report argues that insight into delegitimisation is relevant because the protection of journalists in armed conflict is contingent on their status as civilians. Accusations of participation in combat or terrorism can influence how the legitimacy of attacks on journalists is assessed and can thus impact accountability for violations of international humanitarian law.
Jasmijn de Zeeuw
Legal advisor & researcher – Investigation Unit

Working days: Mon – Fri | Weesperstraat 3 | 1018 DN Amsterdam | The Netherlands
