Many years ago, I had a frantic evening visit from two very old, and very close Jewish friends. They suggested there was something urgent they needed to discuss, and just a short while later, Anna and Martin were sitting opposite from me, sipping some strong exotic alcoholic concoction. I remember, just before they spoke, wondering which one of them had been diagnosed with the terminal illness.
As it happened neither had. Anna was expecting. To many people reading this, confusion now reigns. Why was this not a moment of unbridled happiness?
It is a long and complicated story that I need not retell now, but health issues presented deep and troubling considerations. The pregnancy itself was in many ways unexpected. They consulted all their friends and family. Conflicting opinions were the order of the day.
I gave my advice. What I personally encouraged them to do is of no relevance to this story. Several months after that discussion, Anna gave birth. It was a very problematic but ultimately successful delivery.
Today Haim is a successful and happy adult. If we were to make a list of what constitutes success, Haim would score highly in almost every single one. Yet my word, this Jewish lad has enemies. In a sickening turn of events, some act as if Haim’s life is somehow up for debate. There are actually people who publicly suggest they want Haim killed.
Not the Chinese kid or the boy from Pakistan. Not the Russian or the South African, nor the Brit or the African. They see the little Jewish kid, and it is *only* him they want ‘removed’.
These people are the modern day anti-Zionists.
The Jewish umbrella
This letter in the Guardian is a classic example of twisted logic.
In 1903 the British government offered the early Zionist movement an isolated area of what is now Kenya for a national home for the Jews, a proposal that split the Zionists into opposing camps. One favoured acceptance, but the other insisted that a Jewish homeland, and future Jewish state, could only be in the historic homeland in Palestine. The second camp won, and the proposal was refused. I am one of those who regrets that rejection. Does this make me a Jewish antisemite?
Apparently, because some people opposed a theory in 1903, objecting to today’s reality somehow amounts to the same thing. The Independent are another that throw this false premise around at will.
Radical left and Islamic groups find and use Jewish people willing to promote the smear and elevate them to ‘guru’ status. Ilan Pappe, Max Blumenthal, Ronnie Barkan are a few examples. In the UK, people like Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi are readily sought out by radio stations and newspapers to push this insane idea. As about 90% of Jewish people in the UK see Israel as forming part of their Jewish identity, the tiny minority of ‘opposites’ are rolled out to provide an umbrella against arguments of antisemitism. As if a few Lord Haw Haw‘s could represent the people of Britain in 1940.
It is absurd of course. Whatever theoretical discussions one may have had 80 years ago, it is patently absurd to suggest that anti-Zionism of the 1930’s is the same as opposing Israel today. Israel is not a theoretical discussion; Israel is a vibrant democratic state with a population of over 8 million.
And anti-Zionism TODAY means destroying Israel. It means ignoring the democratic will of 8 million people. Anti-Zionism does not mean having issues with Israeli actions, with Israeli settlements, with Israeli policy. It means taking the only liberal democracy in the Middle East and destroying it.
Which leads to another chronic deception. The people who say criticism of Israel is not antisemitism Of course it isn’t. Criticism of Israel is legitimate, but these anti-Zionists do not want to criticise Israel, they wish to destroy the Jewish nation.
These people do not want you to know the truth, so they blur lines at will. Yes, Israel has issues it needs to address with its neighbours, but internally, Israel is (even living within the circumstances of Islamic radical terrorism at every border) a very healthy society to grow up in. As gays are persecuted throughout the middle east, as Christians are slaughtered, *only* in Israel are you free to be yourself, whichever identity you have chosen to be.
Since shortly after Israel was founded, the radical left began to have issues with Israel. The Cold War created a fault line in the Middle East. As Israel roundly beat the Arabs in war, highlighting issues with inferior Soviet technology, these victories demonised Israel in Soviet eyes. This sees some of the seeds of modern anti-Zionism. Roots in the good old USSR. No surprise then, that whilst classic antisemitism exists in the far right, radical elements on the left take their lead from the fossils of Soviet Russia.
The basic equation is this. Protecting yourself is not racism. The birth of modern Zionism, of Israel was forged as a way of protecting Jewish people from the blatant irrational hatred called antisemitism. Today Jewish people living in Israel protect themselves. It hardly takes a genius to work out how antisemites view Israel.
It is not enough however, just to attack Israel over the way it defends itself, so these anti-Zionists make up ‘facts’ about what is going on inside Israel too. It is why one of the three clauses of BDS is about Israeli citizens, why events such as the upcoming Balfour project in Southwark Cathedral has a film about Israeli citizens too. It is an attempt to blur the lines, to make people confused about where the borders of the problem lies. If you are in a discussion over Israel and anyone mentions Israel’s minorities, they are deliberately blurring lines. The UK has issues with its minorities, so does the USA, everyone does.
That this anti-Zionist movement is ‘non-violent’ is yet another chronic deception. Opposition to Israel is never non violent. Israel has never known a single day of peace. Strategies like #BDS deliberately entice adherents by suggesting theirs is a peaceful struggle. Yet as the leaders of #BDS themselves argue. BDS is ‘one of the tactics’ one of the strategies’ of what they call resistance (an end to the existence of Israel). This from Riya Hassan:
“BDS is a tactic. A tactic within a broad spectrum of tactics that an indigenous people who are fighting for liberation deploy”
So they call for boycott as they celebrate the terrorists who murder innocent civilians in the street. Another ‘strategy of resistance. When you assist one arm of the struggle, you strengthen the other. It would be foolish to argue otherwise.
Haim, the Jewish kid
So Israel faces those that seek to destroy it. Even as they deny this is even what they seek. They wish to bring an end to Zionism, to Jewish self determination, through boycott, through terrorism, through sanctions, through rockets, through divestment and through war.
Because Israel will fight to survive, which makes all of the talk of ‘non violence’ extremely sickening. Israel’s enemies seek to weaken it through delegitimisation, because until know they have been unable to do so through conflict. They will pick up arms. Not just the Jew. But the non-Jew. The Christian, the Muslim, the Druse, the Beduin, the black and the white. For here is another truth. In the UK we call ourselves a multicultural society. Yet Israel’s largest minority is relatively larger that all of the collective minorities in the UK. Israel’s diversity makes the UK look like a white supremacist state.
So these radical anti-Zionists. The ones who make up stories, blur the lines and use false logic. They want people to join them in attacking the Jewish state. Not in theory, but in practice. It isn’t 1903 anymore. Haim lives. They don’t want you to attack the Chinese lad, nor the Russian. Not the Arab, nor the African. They all want you just to help throw stones at the Jew. Of all of the people that live around you, it is only the Jewish one they want to kill.
Now tell me. How is that NOT antisemitic?
Follow, like, donate
Keep up to date, subscribe to the blog by using the link on the page. Follow the FB page for this blog: and follow me on Twitter. Please if you can, also consider making a donation. Mine is an independent action and research is expensive and time consuming. Even producing just one of these piece does take days, sometimes weeks, and whilst I do what I can, there are serious constraints that impact on what is possible. Your assistance can and does make a difference.
*Credit for main picture (child with banner) .. . Richard Millet
12 thoughts on “The story of a Jewish boy called Haim”
“So these radical anti-Zionists […] They all want you just to help throw stones at the Jew. Now tell me. How is that NOT antisemitic?”
Seems like a bit of a straw man argument David.
Gabriel, we all know that you’re the Strawman. Nae brains but an ability to parrot what other bigots say.
not at all Gabriel. But we have long understood you haven’t got a clue about the meaning of anti-Zionism, the aims of BDS and so on. They are people you like to politically ‘understand’ and flirt with….
Don’t be silly. Nobody suggested that stoning Jews, or inciting the stoning of Jews, is anything but anti-Semitism. Hence: straw man.
Gabriel.. well done… you have successfully set up a lovely straw man of your own. I now hope you will entertain us all by thoroughly demolishing it
You’re just too silly.
Because I won’t be led down your little rabbit holes? You are a strange one Gabriel.
The comparison of these people (you forgot to mention Tony Greenstein and Miriam Margolyes) to Lord HawHaw is very apt. He was not the only one: in the 1930s there were 50,000 members of the British Union of Fascists. Many of them fought in the war, fortunately in positions in which they could do no harm, but one of them betrayed members of the SAS to the Nazis.
As an aside, it is clear that the Left hold in deep contempt views that are actually held by the vast majority of Jews, relating to Israel, antisemitism and antizionism. But these same regressive socialists will never, ever, treat the views of other minority groups in this manner. Their actions demonstrate their contempt for our community, and they wonder why we call them antisemites!
The world’s ‘oldest hatred’ is never going to disappear
The problem that the haters have is that the Jews are finally fighting back, and what rankles them even more is that we have friends and supporters that put their heads above the parapet for us
Another absolutely stunning article from you, David. So true. Thank you.
Brilliant article David. A must read. Sharing.
Comments are closed.